I finished Season 1 of Lanterns not knowing going in that Tom King was a co-creator. I found that out somewhere in the middle of the first couple of episodes, and it reframed everything immediately. Because I have a real love/hate thing with King. I love his writing. His ideas are always sharp and he takes the material seriously in a way a lot of superhero storytelling doesn't. The hate part is that he doesn't always stay true to the established characters or the continuity fans know, and that used to bother me more than it does now. Going into this one I had to remind myself: this is its own thing. Not a direct adaptation of the comics. Once I made that adjustment, I was able to just watch it.
The setup is two Green Lanterns working a case on Earth. Hal Jordan is the veteran, played by Kyle Chandler. John Stewart is the newer one, played by Aaron Pierre. A murder pulls them into something bigger, and the show uses that investigation as the spine while it builds out who these two guys are and how they work together. It's closer to a prestige crime drama than a superhero action show, which is either going to work for you or it isn't.
For me it worked, mostly because of the casting. Chandler and Pierre are both exactly right for their roles, and more importantly they have real chemistry. The scenes where the two of them are just talking, figuring each other out, are the best parts of the show. Pierre especially brings something grounded and specific to John Stewart that the character doesn't always get. Chandler does what Chandler does, which is play a certain kind of weathered, competent man better than almost anyone working right now.
The Tom King fingerprints are all over it. The pacing is deliberate. The emotional beats are earned slowly. Some of the choices with the characters will frustrate comics readers who have a fixed idea of who Hal Jordan or John Stewart are supposed to be. I get that frustration. But if you can hold it loosely and let the show be what it is rather than what you wanted it to be, there's a lot here that lands.
Recommended.